Alan Titchmarsh: I've tried every slug control known to man, and these are the only things that have ever worked for me
Alan Titchmarsh is as charming, warming and friendly a man as anyone you'll ever meet. Unless, of course, you're a slug... in which case you'll awaken his ruthless side.


With their squeaky, succulent leaves, it’s no wonder hostas are seen as five-star hotels by slugs and snails. In a damp spring, the marauding molluscs await their moment, honing to perfection their rasping mouthparts so that they can make unbelievable inroads during the space of a single soggy evening. This year, we had a dry start to spring and many hostas managed that crucial spearing of the soil with their tightly scrolled leaves unfurling in pristine condition. Then came the rains and the slugs and snails woke up, but at least we — and our hostas — had a head start.
Like most gardeners, I have tried just about every slug control known to man. I long ago stopped using metaldehyde-based slug pellets, which left the pests writhing in agony and the birds and the ever-rarer hedgehog facing a poisoned diet. The pleasure of hearing a song thrush use a stone as an anvil to crack open a snail for a luncheon of fresh escargot is one of this wildlife gardener’s favourite sounds.
I bridled a while ago when it was suggested that ‘slugs are our friends’ and that out of the 40-odd species that inhabit our gardens only four — the common garden slug, the grey field slug, the large red/black slug and the common keeled slug — attack our plants.
Fine. There may only be four species, but they are common. That means there are a lot of them. They are not and never will be my friends. They are a vital part of the food chain in the garden and that is a situation I will grudgingly live with, which is why it does my heart good to see the moorhens who live on the edge of our wildlife pond having an away day and prowling the border that houses Japanese maples underplanted with hostas in search of a snack or, on a rainy day, a hearty meal.
Crushed eggshells, holly leaves, sharp grit, gravel and even sheep’s wool may be oft recommended as deterrents for both slugs and snails, but they are, at best, unreliable and more often than not totally ineffective. I do not drink enough Colombian or Arabica to carpet my hosta border in coffee grounds and, anyway, I’m not wild about imbuing my garden with an aroma redolent of Starbucks.
"Some varieties are recommended as being resistant — but the snails in my garden did not get the memo"
Apart from going out late in the evening and hand picking the pests (and lobbing them over the hedge onto the country verge), the only things that have worked for me are those rings of copper that resemble a vicar’s clerical collar and which can be pushed into the ground around individual plants to discourage the molluscs from coming any closer. They are reputed (if kept clean) to impart a kind of electric shock to any slug or snail attempting to scale their dizzying height of 1in. Pot feet can be effective if you plant your hostas in large containers, as only those slugs and snails with acrobatic skills — relatively few in number — appear to be able to navigate them.
Avoid placing potted hostas where their leaves can touch a nearby box bush, where snails love to shelter. At night, they’ll hop across the divide and gorge themselves before returning to their customary dorm for their daytime sleep.
Exquisite houses, the beauty of Nature, and how to get the most from your life, straight to your inbox.
Some hosta varieties are more prone to attack than others: those with especially thin and succulent leaves not only provide the best source of food, but are also very quickly turned into the plant equivalent of origami or lace curtains. I have found that ‘Devon Green’ and ‘Halcyon’ are among the least predated. ‘Sum and Substance’ is also recommended as being resistant, but the snails in my garden did not get the memo. There are more than 6,000 registered varieties and many more that are unregistered. The most massive — such as chest-high ‘Jurassic Park’ and ‘T-Rex’ — dwarf even the longer-established ‘Sum and Substance’, but there are also tiny border-edgers, including ‘Lemon Fizz’, that are enjoyable additions to shady beds and borders.
You could be forgiven for thinking that hostas are suitable only for damp, moisture-retentive soil and, indeed, they will thrive best in such hospitable conditions. Yet once the green- and blue-leaved varieties that are most suited to such spots have got their roots down they can be real toughies, even in such seemingly unsuitable situations.
I was thrilled to have a hosta named for me a few years ago. ‘Alan Titchmarsh’ is a variety with rich green leaves that have a creamy yellow streak right down the centre. I try not to imagine that it is in any way a reflection of my character. It is, I have noticed, rarely attacked by slugs and snails. Perhaps they have some respect for the gardener after all.
'Chatsworth: The gardens and the people who made them' by Alan Titchmarsh is out now (Ebury, £35)
Alan Titchmarsh is a gardener, writer, novelist and broadcaster.
-
In pursuit of Nancy: Outrageous star Bessie Carter on bringing the Mitford family to life
The scion of acting royalty Imelda Staunton and Jim Carter reveals why she loved playing Nancy Mitford on screen and what it feels like to act opposite her mother on the stage.
-
Clare Balding and Andrew Balding's day-by-day guide to Royal Ascot 2025
Country Life caught up with Clare Balding and Andrew Balding to get their expert view as Royal Ascot 2025 gets under way.
-
'The whole house shook. Everything was white. For four months, it felt as if we were on Mars': The story behind one of Hampshire's most breathtaking gardens
When Kim Wilkie sculpted a tiered grass amphitheatre behind this 17th-century house, the garden finally settled into place, as Non Morris discovers.
-
Myddleton House: The place that 'will help you learn what true gardening is' is open to everyone, and just 30 minutes from central London
E. A. Bowles created a horticultural playground in the gardens of Myddleton House that was years ahead of its time, and continues to influence even today. Isabel Bannerman takes a look.
-
Wakehurst: 500 years of history, 2.4 billion seeds, 500 acres of planting, and scientists who might just save us all
Charles Quest-Ritson takes a look at the amazing work that's been done to update Wakehurst, Kew's trailblazing outpost in Sussex.
-
A dozen slices of al fresco inspiration from the best designers in Britain
Amelia Thorpe shares her pick of the most beautiful outdoor furniture and accessories to help you make the most of summer.
-
'Victorian magnificence skilfully simplified and distilled': A peek at the restoration of Somerleyton Hall gardens
Recent works have retained the former theatrical splendours of these gardens near Lowestoft, Suffolk, finds Tilly Ware.
-
One of the most spectacular rose gardens in England has come in to bloom two weeks early
It's time to head to Mottisfont — come for the roses, stay for the fascinating exhibition shedding new light on the history of this beautiful Hampshire house.
-
The first new botanical gardens to be created in the UK in almost 200 years is celebrating its 25th birthday
The National Botanic Garden of Wales helped put Carmarthenshire on the map and its Great Glasshouse, designed by modernist architect Sir Norman Foster, was once the largest single-span glasshouse in the world.
-
Chelsea Flower Show 2025: Take a peek behind-the-scenes of the Country Life stand
Discover how interior designer Isabella Worsley and landscape designer Hugo Elwes brought the Country Life Chelsea Flower Show stand to life.