In Focus: A moment in time capturing the gulf between architects’ dreams and residents’ realities

Tony Ray-Jones was one of a generation of photographers who chronicled life in Britain in the 1960s and 1970s, demonstrating the gulf between the dreams of town planners and the reality for the residents. Chloe-Jane Good takes a look at one of his most famous images.

Tony Ray-Jones, Pepys Estate, Deptford, London: children playing on a raised walkway, 1970. Credit: Tony Ray-Jones / RIBA Collections

Pepys Estate, Deptford, London: children playing on a raised walkway, 1970. Credit: Tony Ray-Jones / RIBA Collections

Children play outdoors on an elevated concrete walkway of a housing estate. Metal railings, slabbed planes, residential blocks and a tower surround them. Two vertical rectangles of sky between blocks and tower are visible, but it is a characterless, overcast and impenetrable sky.

Patches of rainwater lie on the ground. There is no greenery in view and the hard, sparse surfaces contrast to the children grouped in play. One girl walks away from the others with a doll in a toy pram and she is alone and stiff in addressing the camera.

In 1970, Architectural Review commissioned street photographer Tony Ray-Jones (1941 – 1972) to document people living on housing estates in Britain to illustrate a special issue on housing as part of the magazine’s ‘Manplan’ series. Pepys Estate, Deptford, London: children playing on a raised walkway, 1970, is one of those photographs. It is now on view until March 3, 2019 at the Wellcome Collection in London, part of an exhibition entitled ‘Living with Buildings’ which explores the positive and negative ways that urban planning shapes lives and health.

‘Manplan’ was initiated by Hubert de Cronin Hastings, the then chairman of the Architectural Press and editor of Architectural Review. The series of eight issues was a brave and radical look at town planning and its effects on real people and their everyday lives. Steve Parnell, an architectural critic and historian, praised the series in a 2014 article in Architectural Review: ‘Manplan focused not on buildings, but on people, and not as individuals, but as a society.’

Prior to ‘Manplan’, the magazine employed mainly staff photographers and the customary style was formal and architectural. The photographers used large format cameras for high definition and controlled compositions. White space, blue skies and the absence of people – except for those that were staged to show scale – were the accepted conventions of the genre.

Architectural photographer John Donat, in a lecture he delivered at RIBA in 1967, criticised this traditional architectural photography, attacking its detachment from the reality of a building in favour of decontextualised forms and details. ‘Why does it never rain in the Architectural Review?’ he pondered.

View this post on Instagram

Larger than life: Michael Scott. The Royal Gold Medal winner's cigarette factory for PJ Carroll featured an infinitely extendable 'free plan' that was years ahead of its time. Pictured: PJ Carroll’s factory in Dundalk, County Louth. The ornamental lake with reflective mobile sculpture, ‘Sails’, by Gerda Froemmel. Credit: John Donat/RIBA Collections When PJ Carroll’s cigarette factory was designed in 1967, his practice had moved into Miesian modernism. But if you’re seeing the influence of Mies’ Crown Hall at IIT, look again. ‘Cross potent’ steel columns made Carroll’s infinitely extendable – as it was, twice. The long-span trusses might have played up his structural expression but the design concept downplayed Mies’ closed, classical monumentality; inspired more by the domestic yet infinite modularity of Katsura Villa in Kyoto. At 2.3m high, the trusses formed the service void, and their 20.6m maximum span became the factory’s de facto module. Trusses would be used to greater effect in Scott Tallon Walker’s 1973 Goulding House in Wicklow, cantilevered dramatically over the River Dargle, but partner Ronnie Tallon thought Carroll’s the firm’s best design. And 12 years after Scott’s death, with its ‘free plan’ easily converting into Dundalk Institute of Technology, time may have proved them right. #RIBA #RIBAJ #RIBAJournal #MichaelScott #RoyalGoldMedal #RoyalGoldMedalwinner #factory #factoryarchitecture #industrial #industrialarchitecture #PJCarroll #Dundalk #CountyLouth #ornamentallake #mobilesculpture #GerdaFroemmel #JohnDonat #RIBACollections #Miesian #modernism #Mies #archilovers #architecturelovers #building #architecturephotography #buildings #archidaily #arquitectura #architect #architexture

A post shared by RIBA Journal (@ribajournal) on

Hastings’ Manplan series took up the implicit challenge, turning away from standard depictions and instead taking a humanist approach, challenging town planning and putting under scrutiny cases where it had impacted negatively on people’s lives. He looked to photojournalists and street photographers who were capturing British life as it occurred.

These photographers, working in the moment, chose not to be hindered by large cameras and instead used fast black and white 35mm film, producing gritty images. The prominence of black in the illustrations was heightened by the design of the magazine spreads which featured unusual amounts of black space printed using a custom matt black ink.

Tony Ray-Jones was one of these trailblazers, a wonderful photographer who, despite his short life (he died from leukaemia at age 30), left a profound legacy. He laid the groundwork for many important British photographers working today, including Martin Parr, who has been particularly inspired by the English seaside resort pictures.

Parr went through the entire Ray-Jones archive in preparation to pay tribute in a joint exhibition in 2013 at London’s Science Museum, which holds in its collection around 2,700 contact sheets and 1,700 35mm rolls of film taken by Ray-Jones.

In the early 1960s Ray-Jones left England to study at Yale University School of Art and went on to New York where he was influenced by American street photographers like Garry Winogrand. On his return to Britain in late 1965, he brought his experience in America to document English way of life as he saw it before it disappeared. The timing was right for urban documentary.

Formally opened in 1966, the Pepys Estate had been expected to improve the lives of many. Instead, when Ray-Jones visited, he  found himself in a dystopian landscape demonstrating the shortcomings of the recently-built social housing schemes.


In Focus: The charmed life of Paddy Leigh Fermor and friends in Greece

The iconic writer Paddy Leigh Fermor and two of his friends in Greece – both artists, one a local man and