The Government has announced four sites that will become eco-towns as part of its scaled-down plans, despite widespread opposition.

Rackheath in Norfolk, north-west Bicester in Oxfordshire, Whitehill Bordon in East Hants and the China Clay Community near St Austell, Cornwall will be the test sites for Gordon Brown’s plans to create thousands of homes in carbon-neutral communities.

However, both the Norfolk and the Cornwall sites must still go through the planning process. Earlier in the week, the Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) expressed concerns that the Government announcement was a challenge to the planning-led process.

The four named sites will be able to bid for a share of £60 million in Government support for local infrastructure, and construction should be under way by 2016, later than originally envisaged by the Government. Housing minister John Healey is making £5 million available to councils to conduct planning work on a second wave of at least six further eco-towns.

Gordon Brown, who initially raise the number of eco-towns from five to 10 in 2007, said: ‘Eco-towns will help to relieve the shortage of affordable homes to rent and buy and to minimise the effects of climate change on a major scale. They will provide modern homes with lower energy bills, energy efficient offices and brand new schools, community centres and services.’

But Grant Shapps, the shadow housing minister, has strongly criticised the Government’s plans: ‘The Conservatives will support genuinely environmentally friendly housing schemes that have local support. But Gordon Brown’s so-called revolutionary eco-town programme is an eco-con, mired in controversy.

‘Underneath the thick layers of greenwash, many of these schemes are unsustainable, unviable and unpopular, but Gordon Brown wants to impose them from Whitehall irrespective of local opinion. All the low-flush toilets in world can’t make dumping a housing estate on green fields somehow eco-friendly.

‘At best, this scheme is a distraction from the more important task of reducing carbon emissions from our existing housing stock. At worst, it’s a discredited gimmick from a discredited Government that’s run out of ideas and run out of steam.’

Government documents reveal that parking in one of the eco-town car parks could cost residents as much as £12,500 per month. Mr Shapps has labelled this a ‘parking tax’, and claims that the eco-towns are being used by Mr Brown to test ‘new taxes and charges on local residents, from bin taxes to massive parking fees’. He feared that if the charges were successful, these ‘stealth’ taxes could be introduced on all new housing developments.

To comment on this article, use the comment box below, or email us at Read more about the countryside

For more news stories like this every week subscribe and save

  • Sarah

    I believe this is really grand standing of the a desperate government in a pre-election period. The location of the site in Cornwall is questionable and it really looks as if the whole plan has not been thought through.

    At the Cornish site is there actually enough work in this area to support this number of new houses? Will local contractors be used or will it all be outsourced to companies outside of the area?

    I believe it would be better to empower the local authorities to encourage all builders to go down the eco house route. This could then become the normal behaviour for them.

    A forward thinking company in Cornwall has been producing eco homes on a smaller scale, this is the type of developments that should be encourgaged.

    Have a look at houses for sale cornwall for some of the examples of eco homes they have produced.

  • Simplyclearances

    We’ve also got one planned in Southern Scotland, the Prince of Wales invested £20m in Dumfries House near Cumnock, and is planning a copycat version of his Dorset eco village.

    I am not quite sure how it will pan out though, because the town of Cumnock has no employment, and is a bit of a driech place. Definitely not an aspirational living kind of town.

    Maybe the Prince of Wale’s development will bring aspiration to the area, I don’t know, I’ll need convincing.