Should we think differently about protecting fine art?
In our experience, collectors rarely just view their collection from an investment perspective and usually have a strong attachment to individual works of art, whether bought, inherited or commissioned — this is a central consideration for us as fine-art insurance brokers. We don’t just review the market to find the right insurance for our client, we look at how we can help prevent distressing claims.
What is the advantage of specialist fine-art insurance?
If you make a claim, your insurance should return you to the same position you were in before the event occurred; this might be replacement, repair/restoration or monetary compensation. Fine art poses unique risks that standard insurance does not address:
- Will you be able to make a full claim for the loss in value of a pair of vases, if only one is damaged?
- If the value of a painting suddenly increases because the artist has died, will your cover automatically increase?
- Will your work of art be insured in transit if you take it abroad or loan it to an exhibition?
- What happens if you have bought a picture in good faith, but a third party later claims title to it (known as defective title)?
Fine-art policies will protect against these risks.
How should you view changes in art value when you are protecting your collection?
Understanding fluctuations in market value has an important influence on the claim outcome. An insurer will base any compensation on the most recent valuations their client has provided, unless values have been pre-agreed — this is one of the reasons it’s important to ensure a collection is regularly reviewed by a professional valuer.
We often advise on the advantages and disadvantages of cover based on the changing market value (low or high auction estimate, retail value) or set pre-agreed values, but it will depend on personal preference. All insurers will differentiate between higher value pieces that require individual valuations and descriptions (known as specified works of art) and lower value art grouped together as unspecified. In the case of a fine-art policy, the specified item limit is at a much higher level, so a piece valued at £50,000 or less may not require an individual description or valuation.
How can you help reduce the risk of loss or damage to fine art?
Fine-art insurance protects against loss, damage or theft, but insurers will ask that certain security measures are in place. We help our clients review security and can advise on alarms, movement sensors, window and door locks and positioning of smoke detectors. If a collection or individual piece is of national or international significance, we suggest it is added to the Art Loss Register’s positive database — this is an internationally recognised record and a deterrent to potential thieves.
What helps recovery following a fine-art claim?
Planning ahead for worst-case scenarios can be hugely helpful and we often work with clients and insurers to develop a disaster recovery plan, which ensures everyone knows how to respond and who to contact in the crucial early stages. Swift emergency removal, specialist storage of fine art and access to restoration specialists are often vital in protecting against further damage or loss. Fine-art insurers offer invaluable experience and provide access to the right expertise when it matters most.
Visit www.castleacreinsurance.com or telephone 01787 211155
-
Alex Hassell and Bella MacLean can’t compete with the raw sex appeal of Rivals’ real star — The CotswoldsBella MacLean and Alex Hassell speak to Meg Walters about season two of Rivals and the sex appeal of the Cotswolds.
-
A beautiful home with a secret garden that's an exquisite oasis in what was once one of the roughest corners of LondonDrawing on the area's industrial and manufacturing heritage, this five-storey house on Wilkes Street is also a horticultural paradise.
-
The best of British: How home-grown stone will be one of the stars on the Country Life stand at the Chelsea Flower ShowCountry Life's stand at RHS Chelsea will celebrate the beauty of Artorius Faber’s home-grown stone.
-
The art of the hand: George Saumarez Smith's design for Country Life at ChelseaGeorge Saumarez Smith will demonstrate the power of pen and pencil when Country Life unveils his hand-drawn design for its stand at the RHS Chelsea Flower Show.
-
Reader event report: An eye to the future at DaylesfordThe magnificent Heritage Barn at Daylesford in the Cotswolds was the setting for an event at which five specialists with a deep understanding of country properties shared their expertise.
-
Reader Event: An eye to the future at Daylesford Heritage HouseWhat changes to a house do most to enhance its aesthetics, function, comfort, sustainability and longevity? On March 24, leading experts in architecture, interior design, craft and restoration will share the secrets to maximising possibilities and protecting value at Daylesford’s magnificent Heritage House in Gloucestershire.
-
Reader Event: Super women at London Design WeekWhat can be learnt from the achievements of the world’s greatest female designers and antique dealers? Which has created the most valuable legacy? What are the secrets of their success? Come and find out at an inspiring event on the first day of London Design Week at 10.30am on Monday, March 9, at the London showroom of luxury lighting brand Hector Finch.
-
Reimagining the past at VaughanIn September 2025, leading designers shared their views on creating interiors with the capacity to last forever.
-
Tetrad: Over half a century of timeless good looksSince 1968, Tetrad has employed a combination of traditional skills and the finest materials to make upholstered furniture that is designed to offer years of comfort.
-
Reimagining the past: A panel discussion with VaughanAt Focus/25 later this month, Vaughan will host an inspiring talk at which leading names in antiques and interiors will explain why understanding the past is vital to designing for the future.
