The best simnel cake revealed

We try before you buy.

1) Small oval Simnel cake in a tin, £11.95, Bettys (0845 600 1919;

Presented in a pretty tin, this elegant little creation is just the right size for two to share. Its strong almond flavour divided our testers, but this was generally held to be a superior Simnel.
Score: 4

Simnel Cake, £20, Fortnum & Mason (0845 300 1707;

Recommended videos for you

Decorated with daffodils and packaged in what looks like a miniature hat box, this smart Simnel is straight out of Mr Selfridge. Sadly, the cake itself failed to deliver the necessary fruity oomph. Safe, but unexciting.
Score: 3

3) Simnel cake, £12, Meg Rivers (01608 682858;
With its speckled marzipan topping, this would look right at home on a farmhouse kitchen table. It’s the most traditional of the Simnels we tastedfruity, moist without being stodgy, and pleasingly spiced.
Score: 4.5

4) Chocolate Simnel cake, £12, The Simply Delicious Cake Company (01584 823470;
And now for something completely different. Those who’ve given up chocolate for Lent might be tempted by a slice of this rich, dense cake studded with fruit and nuts on Easter morning. Unorthodox, but delicious nonetheless.
Score: 3.75

5) Owl Simnel loaf, £12, Konditor & Cook (020-7633 3333;
What a handsome fellow! This quirky loaf won our hearts with its toasted topping, boozy crumb and hint of lemon zest.
Score: 4.75

* Follow Country Life magazine on Twitter

* Subscribe to Country Life and save; Get the Ipad edition