The awkward questions that still need answering about Da Vinci's $450m Salvator Mundi
The dust has now settled following the $450 million sale of Leonardo Da Vinci’s Salvator Mundi. But there are still a few rather difficult questions about the sale to be tackled, according to our art expert Huon Mallalieu.


One of the many weird things about the sale of the Salvator Mundi for $450 million (£337 million) was the repeated claim of Christie’s that it was ‘the last Leonardo painting left in private hands’.
It’s the business of auctioneers to know who owns anything important that might come onto the market and, even when the statement was qualified to ‘fewer than 20 paintings by Leonardo are known to exist and all save for Salvator Mundi are in museum collections’, it will have puzzled at least two owners.
Two versions of the Madonna of the Yarnwinder are now accepted as prime versions from the hand of the master; the Duke of Buccleuch’s is only on loan to the National Galleries of Scotland and the second is in an anonymous American private collection.
The decision to offer the painting, ‘circa 1500’, in a Post-War and Contemporary auction in New York also seemed weird at first sight, but was, in fact, logical and justified by the result.
The clue to that logic is revealed in part of the description: ‘Both of Christ’s hands, the exquisitely rendered curls of his hair, the orb, and much of his drapery are in fact remarkably well preserved and close to their original state’. The implication is that a good deal of it was indeed contemporary, and turns out to be the work of a well-respected New York restorer.
The right hand is convincing, but it’s surprising that the left with the orb should be accepted so uncritically. After all, a scientist of Leonardo’s standing would surely have noticed that images seen through a glass sphere are reversed.
So what did Salvator Mundi look like before conservation? The answer was given on this Instagram post by Tom Campbell, former director of the Metropolitan Museum in New York.
Sign up for the Country Life Newsletter
Exquisite houses, the beauty of Nature, and how to get the most from your life, straight to your inbox.
Not a pretty sight, and the Art Newspaper has run a long analysis discussing what has been done.
Bidders in contemporary sales are perhaps thought to be less concerned about such matters than traditional Old Master buyers. They may also be less concerned with provenance – patchy in this case – or the fact that the 25¾in by 17¾in painting had been offered around the market for the past decade or so.
A further irreverent thought: Christie’s had found a guaranteed buyer at £95 million. As that was very comfortably exceeded, and given the history of defaulting buyers during the Oriental art boom, it must be hoped that the auction house has also laid off against the unnamed buyer, widely suspected to be ‘Chinese or other Asian’.
In the wake of the sale, the bookie Paddy Power was offering 8/1 that the ‘piece is confirmed to be a fake; 16/1 Sale falls through; 25/1 Some-one else comes forward with the “real” painting; 66/1 The piece is damaged in transit to the home of the buyer’.
Actually, I would think that the first of these should have attracted by far the longest odds.
Credit: Two Hacks by George Stubbs (Parker Gallery)
Long-neglected ‘copy’ turns out to be original Stubbs worth £750,000
Gallery owner Archie Parker thought something was amiss when he came across this painting in an online sale catalogue, and
What it feels like to play a violin that cost millions with a bow that cost more than a house
What it feels like to play a violin that cost millions – with a bow that cost more than a house.
Country Life is unlike any other magazine: the only glossy weekly on the newsstand and the only magazine that has been guest-edited by HRH The King not once, but twice. It is a celebration of modern rural life and all its diverse joys and pleasures — that was first published in Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee year. Our eclectic mixture of witty and informative content — from the most up-to-date property news and commentary and a coveted glimpse inside some of the UK's best houses and gardens, to gardening, the arts and interior design, written by experts in their field — still cannot be found in print or online, anywhere else.
-
Graham Norton's elegant East London home hits the market, and it's just as wonderful as you would expect
The four-bedroom home in Wapping should be studied for how well it uses two separate spaces to create a home of immense character and utility.
-
Sign of the times: In the age of the selfie, what’s happening to the humble autograph?
When Ringo Starr announced that he was no longer going to sign anything, he kickstarted a celebrity movement that coincided with the advent of the camera phone and selfie. Rob Crossan asks whether, in today’s world, the selfie holds more clout than an autograph?
-
Chanel takes a cruise around Lake Como
The last Chanel collection designed entirely by the atelier has been unveiled on the shores of Lake Como, in Italy.
-
'Tate Modern has exploded the canon of art history, and transformed the public’s relationship with contemporary art'
Artwork by Louise Bourgeois and Salvador Dali, among others, will be on display for the Tate Modern gallery's 25th Birthday Weekender event.
-
'The watch is Head Boy of men’s accessorising': Ginnie Chadwyck-Healey and Tom Chamberlin's Summer Season style secrets
When it comes to dressing for the Season, accessories will transform an outfit. Ginnie Chadwyck-Healey and Tom Chamberlin, both stylish summer-party veterans, offer some sage advice.
-
Athena: We need to get serious about saving our museums
The government announced that museums ‘can now apply for £20 million of funding to invest in their future’ last week. But will this be enough?
-
Materials, textures, construction, expression: A Brutalist watch on your wrist
Luxury watchmakers are seeking to bridge the gap between two contrasting styles, with exciting results.
-
Folio, Folio, wherefore art thou Folio? Shakespeare set to be auctioned by Sotheby's
Four Folios will be auctioned in London on May 23, with an estimate of £3.5–£4.5 million for 'the most significant publication in the history of English literature'.
-
Curators, art historians and other creative minds share their pick of J. M. W Turner's best works, on the 250th anniversary of his birth
Cold moonlight, golden sunset and shimmering waters are only three reasons to love Turner. On the 250th anniversary of his birth, curators, art historians and other creative minds reveal which of his paintings they’d hang on their walls and why.
-
Boxy but foxy: How the humble Fiat Panda became motoring's least-likely design classic
Gianni Agnelli's Fiat Panda 4x4 Trekking is currently for sale with RM Sotheby's.