Ask six different AI systems for the most beautiful city in Britain and the answer is most likely Edinburgh. Chatronix.ai, a tool that purports to ‘put all your AIs in one place’, compiled a list last week based on the different answers given to the question by ChatGPT, Gemini and four others. Edinburgh came out on top, followed by Bath, York, Cambridge and Oxford. This sounds broadly correct — although, personally, I’d bump Oxford up to bronze (disclaimer: the writer went to the University of Oxford so it's surprising that he didn't bump it up to silver while he was at it).
The methodology, however, raises two important questions. By treating AI’s answers as reliable, we recognise the value of consensus over expert opinion. ChatGPT and Gemini scan not only newspaper articles, but online forums in a bid to give a more accurate answer.
Are they right to?
The second question contends not with the results, but with the impetus for such an experiment. Increasingly, tourists are using AI to plan their holidays. I myself have done it to varying degrees of success; as ever, don’t trust everything you read. This is bad news for mid-tier travel agencies, whose clientele is more likely to cut costs on bespoke itineraries.
Is this how things end for them?
-
A simply perfect thatched cottage in Devon, with charm, walled gardens and all the space you need for family lifeThatched cottages are often pretty, but pretty small — but Julie Harding finds one brings which blends cottage charm with the space of a country manor.
-
How many people pass their driving test first time? Country Life Quiz of the Day, November 13, 2025Test your general knowledge in today's Country Life quiz.
-
Saltmoore hotel review: The place to stay that's woodland retreat, seaside hotel and spa sanctuary all in oneSaltmoore, on the North Yorkshire coast, has barely been open a year but is already earning recognition as one of the finest places to stay in Yorkshire. Toby Keel checked in.
-
Uzbekistan's inaugural Bukhara Biennial turned traditional ways of displaying art on its head and reignited the traditions of the storied Silk RoadEvery week, the news breaks of another art fair — but the Bukhara Biennial is the one to watch, says Skylar Pinchal Coysh.
-
From the Caribbean with love: The other James Bond who wrote the definitive guide to tropical birdsThe Caribbean plays host to a brilliant spectrum of colourful avians, says John Lewis-Stempel, as he revels in a birdwatcher’s paradise. Illustrations by Annabelle King.
-
‘We were off again in a cloud of dust, on the trail of a tiger we eventually ended up making eye contact with’: The art of the Indian safariAn Indian safari is a ‘is a study in patience and intuition’, but that’s no bad thing, says Richard MacKichan.
-
The Scottish survival experience, beloved by Sir David Beckham, Ian Wright and heavyweight CEOs, that's all about learning to appreciate the dizzying brilliance of the natural world againPatrick Galbraith follows in the footsteps of Sir David Beckham — who marked his 50th birthday with a 'survival' experience in the Scottish Highlands.
-
London has long been the private members’ club capital of the world, but New York is finally catching up. Here are five of the bestNew York members clubs are all the rage, but apply wisely, says Owen Holmes.
-
Ashford Castle review: The fantastic five-star hotel in Ireland that the Guinness family once used to show off their wealth and influenceYou’ve seen ‘The House of Guinness’ — well here’s the castle.
-
‘Activities are of the derring-do variety, and the weather is unreliable year round, so it’s useful to be a good sport’: A memorable road trip to the tidal island in Scotland where J. M. Barrie liked to holidayThe opening of three new hotels in Scotland was all it took to convince Jo Rodgers to journey northwards on a road trip with her husband and three young children in tow.
